Fact check: Old unrelated video of bats pouring from a roof linked to the coronavirus outbreak

0
281

During the coronavirus outbreak in China and the WHO declaring it a global health emergency, a video of bats being removed from a roof is making the rounds on social media. It is claimed that these are chrysanthemum bats that carry coronavirus. Hundreds of bats are seen in the video hiding under the roof tiles of a house in Wuhan, China, believed to have originated the virus.

Today’s Anti-Fake News War Room (AFWA) in India determined that the viral video is around nine years old and originated in Florida, USA. There is no connection to the current coronavirus outbreak.

The archived version of the article can be seen here.

AFWA received the message via its hotline (7370007000). The message with the video read: “The main source of the coronavirus has been found. It turns out that many rooftops in Wuhan, Hubei province are heavily infested with chrysanthemum bats, a type of bat that carries the virus in their bodies. When snakes eat these bats, snakes become secondary carriers, and when Chinese people eat these snakes, they become human carriers of the virus and spread to other people through air and other public structural surfaces by coughing, sneezing, runny nose, etc. “

The video is pretty viral on Facebook with similar claims.

Is the video from China?

No, this video is not from China. We found the truth after keyframing the video using the InVid tool and doing a reverse search for one of them. According to some news articles, the video came from Miami where a team of builders from the Istueta Roofing Company were removing tiles to discover the home of hundreds of bats. The news report released in April 2012 also says it was a Mexican fruit bat.

We also found the longer version of the video uploaded by ‘Istueta Roofing’ to their YouTube channel on June 10, 2011. You can see the viral part of the video in sections from 6 minutes 55 seconds.

Istueta Roofing’s website clearly states it has been the most trusted roofer in South Florida since 1985.

Did the coronavirus come from bats?

Possibly yes, but not yet established. A study at UC Berkeley suggests that bats’ strong immune systems encourage virus reproduction, and it is no accident that some of the worst viral disease outbreaks in recent years such as SARS, MERS, Ebola, etc. have come from bats.

However, it has not yet been proven that bats are the original source of the coronavirus. According to the WHO, the animal source of 2019-nCoV, the coronavirus strain responsible for the outbreak of this disease, has not yet been identified.

Is there a connection between coronavirus and bat soup?

There is currently no evidence of this. Some of the videos of people having bat soup are also being circulated, claiming they are responsible for the coronavirus outbreak. However, many of these videos turned out to be older and came from countries other than China. There is no official confirmation that bat soup could be a cause of the deadly virus.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CdEIyyDr2oY

claimBats responsible for the coronavirus outbreak came from the roof of a house in Wuhan.ConclusionThe viral video is around nine years old and is from Miami, USA.

JHOOTH BOLE KAUVA KAATE

The number of crows determines the intensity of the lie.

  • 1 crow: half true
  • 2 crows: mostly lies
  • 3 crows: absolutely wrong